Firecloak's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Rose of Guilt]

Good

Seems really good! I think it could be background music for a sad part. It'd be better if you added onto the tune instead of just repeating it though.

[TFA]

Tom and Jerry

This is pretty good. I think it makes a nice sneaking bgm. Kinda reminds me of the Tom&Jerry sneaking scenes.

[DJO - Serenity]

Nice

I like the soft, relaxing tune.

DJOrsa responds:

Thanks, that's what I was going for. :D

[The Bird]

Loud Guitar Sound

The very loud guitar sound ruined it all. If you lower the volume of the guitar, the sound would be much better.

Dixies responds:

Thnx, I know.
But this is just a joke and not serious made:P

[Where I belong (Another style)]

Yes!

I've been looking for a soft, upbeat song like this for my manga dub since forever! Anyway, I really like how this is a happy song.

[The River Of Shadows]

Cool

This song gives me a sad, brooding feeling. It sounds really nice. Only problem is, it kinda sounds the same throughout the entire thing. (not sure if that's intentional?)

ObsidianSnow responds:

It's really meant as an ambient background piece for a game or movie. Hence how soft it is, and how repetitive. I really wanted to maintain a constant emotion in this, with only a very small climax near the end just to give it some kind of direction. So I don't entirely dissagree on the "sounds the same throughout the entire thing" issue. But yes, it was intentional (for the most part).

If I feel up to it one day, I might remake this one with much more added to it for a listening purpose rather than a mood-setter.

Nonetheless, I really do appreciate your review. Thank you, Firecloak.

[Longing After Fate]

Amazing

This is such a beautiful, dramatic melody. It sounds sad and hopeful at the same time. I'll probably use this in a manga dub I'm doing, with credit of course.

[good event]

Nice and soothing

Sounds great for a reminiscent/flashback scene. I might use this in the future.